ⓘ EQ-5D is a standardized instrument for measuring generic health status. It has been widely used in population health surveys, clinical studies, economic evaluat ..

                                     

ⓘ EQ-5D

EQ-5D is a standardized instrument for measuring generic health status. It has been widely used in population health surveys, clinical studies, economic evaluation and in routine outcome measurement in the delivery of operational healthcare.

EQ-5D is designed for self-completion and as such captures information directly from the respondent, thereby generating data that conforms with the general requirement of all Patient Reported Outcome PRO measures. Alternative modes of administration have also been developed.

Its ease of use and standardized use have resulted in its inclusion in 1.000s of peer-reviewed papers over the past 20 years. The overwhelming majority of these have appeared in clinical journals.

When used in economic evaluation EQ-5D preference weights are combined with time to compute quality-adjusted life years QALY. QALYs gained is used as the outcome in cost-utility analysis which is a type of economic evaluation that compares the benefit and cost of health care programs or interventions. Many countries generated a value set preference weights of their own population and have used it for estimating QALY to make decisions in resource allocation. There are currently 171 language versions of EQ-5D questionnaire available. EQ-5D is one of the most commonly used generic health status measurement, and its good validity and reliability have been reported in various health conditions.

                                     

1. Development

EQ-5D was first introduced in 1990 by the EuroQol Group. This group was initially formed in 1987 with the researchers of multidisciplinary areas from five European countries; Netherlands, UK, Sweden, Finland, and Norway. They worked cooperatively with the aim of developing an instrument which is not specific to disease but standardized and can be used as a complement for existing health-related quality of life HRQoL measures. Other required characteristics of the new instrument were capable of being sent as a postal questionnaire for self-completion, easy to complete, applicable to everyone, can produce a single index value, and can take into account the health status worse than dead’.

                                     

2. Components

The EQ-5D questionnaire has two components: health state description and evaluation.

In the description part, health status is measured in terms of five dimensions 5D; mobility, self-care, usual activities, pain/discomfort, and anxiety/depression. Mobility dimension asks about the persons walking ability. Self-care dimension asks about the ability to wash or dress by oneself, and usual activities dimension measures performance in "work, study, housework, family or leisure activities". In pain/discomfort dimension, it asks how much pain or discomfort they have, and in anxiety/depression dimension, it asks how anxious or depressed they are. The respondents self-rate their level of severity for each dimension using three-level EQ-5D-3L or five-level EQ-5D-5L scale.

In the evaluation part, the respondents evaluate their overall health status using the visual analogue scale EQ-VAS.

                                     

2.1. Components EQ-5D-3L

When EQ-5D was first developed, the scale used in the health state description part was three-level; having no problems, having some or moderate problems, being unable to do/having extreme problems. As an example, three levels of mobility dimension are phrased as "I have no problems in walking about", "I have some problems in walking about", and "I am confined to bed". The respondents are asked to choose one of the statements which best describes their health status of surveyed day. Rated level can be coded as a number 1, 2, or 3, which indicates having no problems for 1, having some problems for 2, and having extreme problems for 3. As a result, a persons health status can be defined by a 5-digit number, ranging from 11111 having no problems in all dimensions to 33333 having extreme problems in all dimensions. 12321 indicates having no problems in mobility and anxiety/depression, having slight problems in self-care and pain/discomfort, and having extreme problems in usual activities. There are potentially 243 =3 5 different health states.



                                     

2.2. Components EQ-5D-Y

A youth version of the EQ-5D-3L descriptive system was developed for self-completion by children and younger people. It includes equivalent dimensions to the original EQ-5D-3L, phrased so as to be more easily understood and relevant for younger people. The dimensions are: mobility, looking after myself, doing usual activities, having pain or discomfort and feeling worried, sad or unhappy.

                                     

2.3. Components EQ-5D-5L

Although its brevity contributed a lot for the wide use of EQ-5D, the three-level scale showed some limitations. The major drawback is that it has much fewer descriptive capability of health status compared to other generic instruments. For example, the Health Utilities Index Mark 2 and Mark 3 HUI 2 and HUI 3 and the Short Form 6D SF-6D can define 24.000, 972.000, and 18.000 unique health states, while EQ-5D-3L can do only 243. As a consequence, it suffers from ceiling effects which are present when participants’ scores reach the best possible score of the instrument. Several studies reported ceiling effects for the EQ-5D-3L. EQ-5D-3L showed low sensitivity to small and medium health changes and low responsiveness to detect clinical change especially for the conditions such as schizophrenia, alcohol dependency, hearing impairment and limb reconstruction. To improve such constraints of the three-level scale, the new version of EQ-5D with five-level scale was developed EQ-5D-5L. The number of levels of severity was increased to five in this new version; having no problems, having slight problems, having moderate problems, having severe problems and being unable to do/having extreme problems. The new version can define 3.125 =5 different health states. Some of the wordings of the scale were revisited to be clearer and the instruction for EQ-VAS was simplified. No changes were made for the five dimensions.

The validity and reliability of the EQ-5D have been assessed for the different language versions and various health conditions, including cancer, type 2 diabetes, COPD, asthma, and cardiovascular disease, and so on. The 5L system showed improved responsiveness compared to the 3L system, and also good validity and reliability. EQ-5D-5L has also been recommended to the elderly population as a generic health status measurement, in combination with other supplementary measurements to capture all related aspects in their quality-of-life.

                                     

2.4. Components Visual analogue scale EQ-VAS

Visual analogue scale is the second part of the questionnaire, asking to mark health status on the day of the interview on a 20 cm vertical scale with end points of 0 and 100. There are notes at the both ends of the scale that the bottom rate 0 corresponds to the worst health you can imagine", and the highest rate 100 corresponds to "the best health you can imagine". In the EQ-5D-3L version, the respondents has to draw a line from the box on the questionnaire to the scale indicates the health state of the interviewed day, while the EQ-5D-5L version asks to mark X on the scale to indicate the todays health and write the number of the scale marked in the empty box on the questionnaire. A well-known limitation of visual analogue scale is end-of-scale bias that respondents are less likely to use the extreme ends of the scale for rating their health status. However, it is still useful and the simplest direct method for valuing health-related quality of life HRQoL weights.



                                     

3. Valuation process

Once the health status is assessed from the description part, the 5-digit number can be converted into a preference weight which is also referred to as a single weighted index score. It can be done by using methods for generating HRQoL weights, such as visual analogue scale VAS, the time-trade-off TTO, and the standard gamble SG. The choice of the valuation methods can vary. The initial purpose of having visual analogue scale in the EQ-5D questionnaire was to get preference weights using the scale, but the time-trade-off has become favored because it is a "choice task", not a "rating task" which easily involves some scaling bias. Time-trade-off is recommended when performing cost-utility analysis using quality-adjusted life year QALY as an outcome, but other methods could be chosen for different type of analyses. A value set was developed using time-trade-off in many countries, including the United Kingdom, United States, Spain, Japan, and Germany. The index score of a value set derived from the general population sample can be regarded as a societal valuation of the respondents health state" in that country. In contrast, the scores from the visual analogue scale in the questionnaire indicates the respondents own assessment of his/her health status". A value set derived from the general population sample has been criticized for a lack of a compelling theoretical support.



                                     
  • The Dongfeng EQ 240 EQ 2081 export name Aeolus is a 2. 5 tonne capacity, six - wheel drive troop cargo carrier truck developed and built by Dongfeng Motor
  • EQ Virginis is a flare star in the constellation of Virgo. It is an orange dwarf of spectral type K 5 Ve and is a member of a IC 2391 moving group. The moving
  • EQ Pegasi is a nearby binary system of two red dwarfs. Both components are flare stars, with spectral types of M4Ve and M6Ve respectively, and a current
  • The EQ 245 EQ 2100 is a 3. 5 tonne capacity, six - wheel drive troop cargo carrier truck developed and built by Dongfeng Motor Corporation and used by the
  • Encephalization quotient EQ encephalization level EL or just encephalization is a relative brain size measure that is defined as the ratio between
  • EQ Office is a real estate investment company that owns 80 office properties comprising 40 million square feet. The company is owned by funds managed by
  • The Dongfeng EQ 2102 is a 3. 5 tonne capacity troop cargo carrier truck developed and built by Dongfeng Motor Corporation and used by the People s Liberation
  • volume knobs. In the field of audio electronics, the term equalization or EQ has come to include the adjustment of frequency responses for practical
  • Empathy quotient EQ is a psychological self - report measure of empathy developed by Simon Baron - Cohen and Sally Wheelwright at the Autism Research Centre
  • The Mercedes AMG F1 W10 EQ Power was a Mercedes - Benz Formula One racing car designed and developed under the direction of Aldo Costa, James Allison, Mike
  • ε1 4. The major terms in eq 17 and eq 18 are those that contain time derivatives. From eq 17 and the space components of eq 18 one has t g
  • Vari - Mid EQ To achieve his signature sound Fieldy tunes his basses to A, D G, C, F, turns the midrange all the way off and brings down the EQ all the
  • Interventional EQ Fieldwork also known as PIEQF can be seen as the seminal work of New Zealand born installation and performance artist D V. Rogers. This